Melee weapon question (in General)


noneedforthese June 12 2007 3:48 AM EDT

I guess it applies to ranged weapons too:

It was inspired by Defender's massive dagger. Do weapons have hugely varying +to hit upgrade costs?

My argument for varying upgrade costs (if it doesn't exist already) is that you should be more agile with really light weapons, and a simple dx penalty to 2 handed weapons just doesn't seem fair. There should also be differences between 1-handed weapons, and 2-handed weapons. I could imagine ELS becoming much more attractive if it was
a. much cheaper to upgrade
b. had better chance to hit in general
c. gave dex bonus
d. gave skill bonus
and etc. And I'm not even just talking about ELS, I mean 1 handed weapons in general :)
I'd love to see a +400 dagger doing quint hits every time or something hehehe....

Flamey June 12 2007 4:32 AM EDT

"b. had better chance to hit in general "

1-handed weapons have a better base CTH than 2-handed weapons.

QBOddBird June 12 2007 5:38 AM EDT

Yes, the +to hit costs vary.

Yes, it is very cheap for the dagger.

ResistanZ2 [The Knighthood] June 12 2007 6:02 AM EDT

Eh.. how come dagger isn't listed under most valuable items? How can I find out who has the biggest dagger in CB? :\

QBOddBird June 12 2007 6:03 AM EDT

Items Overview, Squid jugs

noneedforthese June 12 2007 6:39 AM EDT

Cool, I didn't know. I went to the weapons wiki (had a very brief look heh) and couldn't find anything on it.
BUT, in your wise opinions, do the benefits outweigh or at least match the disadvantages in certain strategies? Is an ELS (rather than BoNE) _ever_ a good idea for any strat?

TheHatchetman June 12 2007 12:46 PM EDT

My opinions on this matter are heavily biased, as I've just began the purchase of one of the largest 1H weapons in the game. But it would make more sense to make them cheaper + and more expensive x than 2H weapons...
This thread is closed to new posts. However, you are welcome to reference it from a new thread; link this with the html <a href="/bboard/q-and-a-fetch-msg.tcl?msg_id=0028Vv">Melee weapon question</a>