DD spell idea (in General)
February 27 2008 9:46 AM EST
Spell name: Lifeline
Effect: 10% of spell level (50% if cast on one minion)
Lifeline directly drains 60% off the damage done to target minions back to the caster as extra HP. Here is the catch... AMF and GA backlashes send 30% of the damage done to the caster back to each target because of the Lifeline effect.
February 27 2008 10:25 AM EST
if I'm reading that correctly it seems extremely rigged you're giving the caster the range of FB with a VA effect which archers can't get effectively unbalancing ranged in your favour.
This spell would also nullify the whole point of AMFs backlash by sending it's damage at the AMF caster anyways which no other skill can do, tanks can't get rid of EC cast on them so i believe there shouldn't be any built in EO nerfs.
Overall it would have to do next to no damage to be considered balanced by anyone.
If any spell gets added i vote for FoD.
February 27 2008 10:28 AM EST
So, a defensive DD spell?
Not sure who would be able to invest in this to make it worthwhile... Not much point in keeping your team alive if you aren't dealing out any damage, and it is hard to have two large minions on one team (one for defense, one for damage).
Then again, because of the defensive nature of this, the Lifeline DD mage would almost be like an enchanter (but would have to stay alive to work).
I would worry that if this worked, it would be TOO powerful -- it would be yet another regeneration spell to go along with PL/TSA/VA, etc. It would make those tight 4-minion PL/Wall builds that much more impossible to crack, even with AMF (because one could use NSes and basically just have a positive healing spell...)
Nifty idea, I just worry that people would either disregard it entirely, or it would be too powerful. It's like an AS enchanter except it gets to keep firing every round as long as it is alive...
February 27 2008 10:44 AM EST
If sutekh has this right i think it would belong more as a skill because it isn't really doing Direct Damage to anything in which case it's just an improved PL
February 27 2008 10:52 AM EST
Well, except for the AMF aspect, which is why it sort of fits as a DD... But I'm not sure I have it right, since I am not sure it is self-targeting from the original description...?
Yes, it does sound a lot like PL, except the caster actually gains HP by the sound of it, not just reducing it.
Fairys: it does do damage, though. You ever played Pokemon? It's like Leech Life: you do a little damage, and half of the damage you do comes back to you as HP.
I think it's a nice idea.
"Here is the catch... AMF and GA backlashes send 30% of the damage done to the caster back to each target because of the Lifeline effect."
Let's say I have this DD spell trained, and I get hit with GA. Does this sentence mean that 30% of the GA damage I receive goes back to the target that I originally hit, or does it mean that 30% of the damage I take from GA goes back to the minion I hit as extra/regenerated HP? If it is the latter, as I suspect, then good job. I think it's excellent.
"It's like an AS enchanter except it gets to keep firing every round as long as it is alive..."
AS casts on all minions on the team, whereas this sounds to me like it helps to keep only the damage dealer (i.e. minion with Lifeline trained) by giving HP only to that minion.
February 27 2008 11:00 AM EST
For clarification, this...
"AMF and GA backlashes send 30% of the damage done to the caster back to each target because of the Lifeline effect."
... means that part of the AMF and GA backlash damage get transfered back to the targets as extra HP *for them*. So the caster is actually sending HP back to the targets.
In other words, if the Lifeline spell level is not high enough, the targets can potentially end up gaining extra HP because of the HP transfered from the caster to them via AMF/GA backlash.
So the Lifeline created between the caster and the targets would be bi-directional.
February 27 2008 11:10 AM EST
Sorceress takes damage from his own Lifeline (22641)!
Sorceress's Lifeline hit A Target
Sorceress Gains HP from a Lifeline to A Target (30703)!
A Target Gains HP from a Lifeline to Sorceress (6792)!
February 27 2008 11:35 AM EST
I like the idea a lot, but like it's been said, with VA, TSA and PL, this could(and probably will) overpower multi-minion teams.
Aside of that, it's a great DL(direct life) spell.
February 27 2008 11:36 AM EST
What about Powerline instead?
Sorceress calls teammate from his own Powerline (22641)!
Sorceress's Powerline called A Teammate
Sorceress Gains HP from a Powerline call to A Teammate (30703)!
A Squirrel gets zapped on the Powerpole (6792)!
February 27 2008 12:48 PM EST
i have to agree with ling and sut this would overpower 4 minion teams with pl because of it's range(5 rounds of extra hp with a hoc if you don't wear a corn) it would have to resemble an underpowered CoC to be somewhat fair.
A 60% drain couldn't be laughed at at higher levels 20% like a morg or BoTH might make it a little more balanced.
February 27 2008 1:09 PM EST
"A 60% drain couldn't be laughed at at higher levels 20% like a morg or BoTH might make it a little more balanced."
Could be true. The numbers were just thrown out there and can be adjusted. However, I am convinced that the HP granted to the opponents using GA and/or AMF would definitely balance the % out.
AMF, for example, deals a constant backlash unaffected by AC. So multi-minion teams capable of casting a 40% or 50% AMF would really be devastating to Lifeline characters. For example, opposing minions wearing MgS combined with another minion casting a high AMF or GA could actually gain more HP than the damage dealt from Lifeline.
I think it would really generate new and interesting strategies.
February 27 2008 1:30 PM EST
I think it would necessitate longer # of rounds, as well...
February 27 2008 7:46 PM EST
Well, for me, I would prefer it to be a single target spell, like MM, but with the HP leech spread across your own minions. I'm not sure if that would shift it towards the overpowered or underpowered side, but to me it makes more sense. Upping the % effect, and lowering the % drained would make more sense if it was targeting one minion. I would certainly use a front-to-back RANGED DD spell :D.
About the AMF/GA damage thingy - I would hope only AMF affected Lifeline's amount of reabsorbed HP by the opponent. I also think that the damage taken by the opponent and the damage reabsorbed should simply be combined at any rate - if the damage from AMF is static, then the amount of damage returned as HP to the opponent will also be static, so why not simply combine the two by reducing the displayed damage accordingly? In this way, it would be a static reduction of damage taken, AND HP absorbed by the caster. GA is just funky, so yeah.
February 27 2008 7:58 PM EST
Oh, and as a sidenote, does VA, MH, and BoTH leech let you gain HP above whatever you started with? Just wondering in case Talion hadn't thought of whether HP would be capped or not. I really, REALLY think it would be interesting to see non-dispellable (although countered in other ways) HP being generated on a team.
February 27 2008 9:29 PM EST
yes they do, A!A!
February 28 2008 1:19 AM EST
Also, ToE/NS reduces AMF, DM reduces GA, so:
single minion, enough HP, evasion, lifeline, DM, pro if you want
HoC/corn, ToE, NS (definitely better than AG now), etc.
Seems powerful, all leech effects get better with ToE (your HP is worth more), but if it also increases the actual effect of the DD... decay you don't even worry about since you're leeching all day.
And being single minion also prevents "spread HP" dilution.
February 28 2008 7:11 AM EST
Would be very weak against any team of more than 2 minions. 5% effect would do little damage and kill nothing in ranged. Any team with base Decay and a smallish DD spell would own your single minion Lifeline character in its sleep.
February 28 2008 11:13 AM EST
The problem I've always seen brought up with this is how it lengthens battles, since a skill/DD like this is best used with a defensive setup...it would be a struggle not to stalemate
February 28 2008 11:30 AM EST
Well, OB, considering how much focus there is on the first four rounds of battle, I wouldn't mind seeing a defensive spell that lengthens it :).
February 28 2008 11:31 AM EST
...except adding more HP isn't going to matter in the case of being wiped out in the first couple rounds. If it was close, then yeah, that could extend it. Generally, though, ranged is a hit-or-miss thing, and if they hit, you lose...
February 28 2008 11:37 AM EST
Well, you did say that Lifeline would be most likely in a defensive set-up, and although ranged damage is still massive, I don't think it's improbable that Lifeline would help against MM and FB, and, depending on which version of Lifeline you take, SoD as well.
February 28 2008 11:40 AM EST
"... it lengthens battle ... it would be a struggle not to stalemate."
Ok... and that is a problem because?
I think most high MPR fights do not last long enough (except when using those awful Evasion/RoBF strategies).
Having a way to make more fights last past the 15th round would be fun.
And AA... I like my version of the spell better. :P
February 28 2008 1:15 PM EST
"Ok... and that is a problem because?"
Simple: Because win, lose, draw is all better than a stalemate. It's the only scenario in which you get NOTHING, whether you're the attacker or defender.
Not only that, but once you enter the ~20th round consistently in battles, randomness begins to determine whether you get a win/loss or stalemate. That's REALLY lame.
And checking all the top characters, the majority consistently get between 5 and 15 rounds, which is a pretty safe zone. Sutekh tilts it towards the bottom end of that scale, novice and Little Devil tilt it towards the upper end, etc.
February 28 2008 1:29 PM EST
"Simple: Because win, lose, draw is all better than a stalemate."
That is not a problem, it's a personal preference.
February 28 2008 1:32 PM EST
...but I'm somewhat sure that everyone prefers to win, lose, or draw, rather than get zero rewards. Correct me if I'm wrong, but isn't that the only way to gain MPR?
February 28 2008 7:37 PM EST
Well, first of all, I certainly don't believe Lifeline would lengthen things to the point of a stalemate. If it is, then obviously something would need to be adjusted.
Now, someone is going to skewer me for this, but looking at the top is not always a completely accurate representation of things. Of course I'm not saying that it should be disregarded completely, but if you take the point of view that Lifeline would be a balanced DD spell (as it should be) with specific counters, then stalemates shouldn't be a problem - no attacker is going to train a skill that makes you stalemate every single time ;/.
I still really like the idea behind this spell. A new way to generate HP for the non-Tank teams :).
This thread is closed to new posts.
However, you are welcome to reference it
from a new thread; link this with the html
<a href="/bboard/q-and-a-fetch-msg.tcl?msg_id=002Mba">DD spell idea</a>