January 19 2005 5:21 PM EST
- cost per upgrade point is now constant
- dmg output per point lowered
- protects against other CBF dmg as well as Fireball
- amount of fire protection capped at 4k per point
January 19 2005 5:30 PM EST
You guys complained enough, you better thank him.
January 19 2005 6:01 PM EST
/me starts doing the "Nerf DM!" chant.
January 19 2005 6:27 PM EST
I need everything spelled out. So a CoBF +10 would block a level 40k fireball?
January 19 2005 6:35 PM EST
I think 4k damage :)
January 19 2005 6:40 PM EST
Just tested things out with my cobf i just upgraded to +2.
I noticed almost no reduction in the FB damage my minion with it receives. So I suspect that it lowers the effective level of the opponents FB by 4k each level of the +.
Just my observations.
Granted my CoBF is only +1 it doesn't seem to block any damage from fireball at all.
kraything Score / Power Rating: 37 / 41
Bolly's Fireball hit Deli Melt 
Bolly's Fireball hit Deli Melt 
Bolly's Fireball hit Deli Melt 
He obviously can't have that much trained into his fireball, so do I have to go for +2 to get it to block anything or what?
January 19 2005 7:08 PM EST
damage blocking should be fixed now
January 19 2005 7:48 PM EST
Yep, it is fixed now.
Thanks, overall the changes should be for the positive. Just that they were sudden and kind of unexpected (for me).
Don't worry IA! I'm still doing no damage to Susan. But at least I now know it is possible to do so! ;)
And my score has stopped dropping to 50K every time I log off, where people half my PR with CBF s were beating 7 kinds of brick dust out of me every chance they got. ;)
The 4K per point works really well. Especially when combined with reduced damage in ranged rounds (some people I can only damage when my FB reaches melee), and with FB s damage spread over multiple minions (again, I have to wait till all other minions are dead before my FB does enough damage to hurt CBF wearers).
Ok. So I might be dense here. But a +3 Cobf blocks my 69k Level fireball. Shouldn't the 4k per '+' be applied to the FB level and not damage?
Buffet, mine's at 62k, for anyone to block that entirely would cost 1.5mil + expenses from buying that cloak. Whereas they'd have to spend a few 100k to block it when it's going by damage.
Not many people have 1.5mil NW, let alone 1.5mil to drop into a cloak just to defend against FB. And if they do spend that much, well they deserve to be blocking it.
Your wrong.. my FB is higher than yours and a +3 cobf blocks mine
Buffet, my FB is far lower than yours and MrC's, but I do around 20K damage in melee with my FB. That's a +6 to totally absorb mine... Are you looking at the reduced damage you do in ranged? Or the reduction for hitting multiple minions?
Do you 20k in damage to the minion wearing the Cobf, or to the other minions?
Other minions. It's my average melee damage.
Yours must be a bit higher than that...
Of course i damage other minions, they aren't wearing the CoBF. Only the minion wearing the CoBF is protected. And what I am saying is that a +3 cobf is blocking my 68k level FB which i don't think is right.
As Tibike77 might say:
CoBF absorbs (substracts, whatever) 4k points of (fire) damage from each damage-dealing source per enchant point for the wearer. If X enemy minions are present and you do to them damages between 7k and 9k in one certain round, a CoBF+1 wearer would take 3-5k damage instead, a CoBF+2 wearer would take 0-1k damage instead, and a CoBF+3 wearer would never take any damage in that specific round. The rest take normal damage.
Dude, that's also what I said above...
"The 4K per point works really well. <snip> and with FB s damage spread over multiple minions (again, I have to wait till all other minions are dead before my FB does enough damage to hurt CBF wearers)."
I was asking in response to your;
"Ok. So I might be dense here. But a +3 Cobf blocks my 69k Level fireball"
As a +3 CBF doesn't block my 40K level FB when a single minion and in melee...
I take it your FB is not being blocked by a single minion in melee?
I guess the reduction works on damage rather than FB level because the same routine deals with reduction of other CBF splash damage and the FB friendly fire splash as well.
Buffet, as you say, your FB is bigger than mine so I don't see how it's being blocked.
Against a single minion without a CoBF I do up to 20k damage (in ranged), which would mean a +3 would block 12k of that which would drop it to anything up to 8k damage, in ranged.
Against multiple opponents it's obviously reduced damage which would mean that a +3 CoBF would block my FB and most likely yours too, but that doesn't mean you can't get any damage through, your FB will still kill the others just as easy and then you get some big hits against the last minion even if it does have a CoBF.
Yes when your opponent has a CoBF your chances of winning are much smaller but no that's not overpowered.
I've been discussing this with Tibike, and it's the "- cost per upgrade point is now constant" that's the most worrying.
Will the increasing xp cost to improve FB be able to keep up with a fixed CBD cost? In the long run, will FB have any hope versus high NW cloaks?
Do we just have to wait for time to tell?
January 20 2005 10:36 PM EST
Or, you could just assume that I'm not stupid.
Just to clarify (for myself) how it works:
Hypnotoad has 93 in AC, 36 vs. magic, and (4) in Protection
I have done some fights against The Noble one, who has a +5 CBF:
With my +7 CBF on:
HypnoToad burns from the flames surrounding Altus (26477)
With my +7 CBF off:
HypnoToad burns from the flames surrounding Altus (22262)
How is this possible???
Weren't my CBF meant to guard against his CBF damage????? Now it looks more like it improves it.
January 29 2005 2:49 PM EST
You only tested it ONCE! There is randomness built into damage...test it a bunch of times and take an average.
I've tested it three times.. but it kinda hurts for my clan, doing it. These are the results from the two other tests:
HypnoToad burns from the flames surrounding Altus (19289)
HypnoToad burns from the flames surrounding Altus (26751)
HypnoToad burns from the flames surrounding Altus (19713)
HypnoToad burns from the flames surrounding Altus (21074)
As it seems to me.. there is no impact, whether I use CBF or not.
January 29 2005 7:37 PM EST
January 29 2005 8:08 PM EST
Sorry for the question.
But if you have a minion with a CBF on and he attacks via melee someone with one also equipped, does your cloak protect vs the flame damage on the others CBF?
January 29 2005 10:39 PM EST
Did not see or forgot the very first response. So again im an idiot.
Not the first time and I guarantee it wont be the last.
This thread is closed to new posts.
However, you are welcome to reference it
from a new thread; link this with the html
<a href="/bboard/q-and-a-fetch-msg.tcl?msg_id=001ANh">CBF changes</a>