deifeln
April 5 2006 9:00 AM EDT
Many people see PL as an Axbow/Exbow nerf. What are your thought on the following idea to make these items useful again?
1. Make Axbow and Exbow target opponent's minion with the highest dexterity and strength respectfully.
2. Make PL not effect dex/strength drains and only damage.
Maelstrom
April 5 2006 9:23 AM EDT
#1 is already the case...
What exactly would respectful targeting of one's opponents read like, in a play-by-play? ;)
suggestion: if PL minion can't absorb as much ST (DX) as targeted minion would have become drained, than absorb ST/DX from targeted minion instead.
So ST/DX drain would be the same link as it's already with HP.
GnuUzir
April 5 2006 10:13 AM EDT
Good idea stabilo...
I'm with you.
My formulation is a bit unclear, so I'll give an example:
Minion A, 1000HP, 10ST, 10DX, enough PL
Minion B, 1000HP, 1000ST, 1000DX
opponent shoots with axbow 100 damage and 20% dx-drain (which is here 200DX)
result after fight as it's now (better: as i understood it)
A: 910HP, 10ST, -190DX
B: 1000HP, 1000ST, 1000DX
with my change this would be:
A: 910HP, 10ST, 10DX
B: 1000HP, 1000ST, 800DX
because 20% from 1000DX is more DX than minion A has.
If minion A had 200DX the result would become:
A: 910HP, 10ST, 0DX
B: 1000HP, 1000ST, 1000DX
and so minion A was able to absorb the DX drain, just as he does with the HPs.
Maybe in a month or 4 Jon will notice he made them useless, then make a change.
Tezmac
April 5 2006 11:41 AM EDT
My thoughts were that either:
A) The drain should still be passed along, but the damage sent to the PL minion, like previously mentioned
or
B) The cost of upgrading the damage modifier should be significantly dropped but the amount of drain per x dropped as well. This would allow for more damage to be dealt while keeping drain levels still related to upgrade costs.
This thread is closed to new posts.
However, you are welcome to reference it
from a new thread; link this with the html
<a href="/bboard/q-and-a-fetch-msg.tcl?msg_id=001lcY">Axbow/Exbow thoughts</a>