So, there's a lot of controversy surrounding the Arizona Immigration bill that was recently passed. The concern resides in the police discretion to determine 'reasonable suspicion' of being an illegal alien. Critics say it opens up the possibility for racial discrimination.
Here's a link to the bill
http://www.azleg.gov/legtext/49leg/2r/summary/s.1070pshs.doc.htm
A few significant clauses:
Enforcement
1. Requires a reasonable attempt to be made to determine the immigration status of a person during any legitimate contact made by an official or agency of the state or a county, city, town or political subdivision (political subdivision) if reasonable suspicion exists that the person is an alien who is unlawfully present in the U.S.
Trespassing by Illegal Aliens
11. Specifies that, in addition to any violation of federal law, a person is guilty of trespassing if the person is:
a) present on any public or private land in the state and
b) is not carrying his or her alien registration card or has willfully failed to register.
12. Requires, in the enforcement of this statute, the final determination of an alienメs immigration status to be determined by:
a) a law enforcement officer who is authorized to verify or ascertain an alienメs immigration status or
b) a law enforcement officer or agency communicating with ICE or the U.S. Border Protection.
My take:
After reading the bill, it honestly sounds like it's intentions are perfectly reasonable. Considering how I was seeing the bill portrayed, I was surprised to not find any blatant problems with the bill. It seems to me like it has the potential for abuse, but at least on paper it seems pretty reasonable. I'd hope any abuse of the powers would surface if they were to occur. Also, I doubt the bill will do much to solve the overarching problem.
My take on Immigration overall:
I would like there to be reform, such as the proposed guest worker program. Ideally, a more streamlined process for people who genuinely want to work here and not just take advantage, as well as a way for the Government to keep tabs on them. I expect the number that want to take advantage is far smaller than those that just want to work. At the very least, considering the large number of illegals currently residing in the United States, our current approach seems silly; there has to be a better one even if a guest worker program is not it. It's like trying to keep the tide from coming in. However, Arizona definitely wouldn't be able to enact any vast Immigration Reform on their own, so I can't fault them.