S&F weapon advice (in Off-topic)

pretty simple I ended up with 2 weapons & am unsure which I should use here are the stats

169-261 (~215) all +166
Dam: 31738-49016
HP: 516560
Crit: 41.93%

or

184-252(~218) DX +336
DAM: 38456-52668
HP: 443520
Crit: 37.16%

I always prefer to choose the all bonus ones. I've still got my Rocket Bow from 30-40 levels ago in preference to better straight Dex bows.

I'd use #1.

use the 2nd one. All bonus items suck as for you Str and Int do almost nothing.

But Con and Luck don't suck so you still get +166 to 3 useful stats (+498 total) instead of +336 to one stats.

Also, while STR and INT don't have much use, they aren't useless. You will reduce the damage you receive from Tanks and Mages a little.

Lastly, it gives you more options when deciding on single stat items in the future since you don't feel like you are trading 400 in one stat for 400 in another.

Obviously, I would go with the first.

Go with the second one... bigger hits causing higher damage is immensely better.