Research on the new ToE (in General)

So, lostling asked me to do a little research on the new damage mitigation for the ToE. It's late at night, and I'm running on BA regen, so feel free to do your own testing, but this is what i'm finding...

With a ToE of about 500k Tattoo Level, the Endurance damage reduction I'm receiving is approximately 3.4% for AMF, and about 10% for fireball damage.

After about a dozen fights, both with the ToE equipped and unequipped, I found myself reducing AMF damage by approximately 17,000 damage every round. As for fireball damage, the tattoo seemed to be reducing damage by about 50,000 every round (of course the fireball damage reduction is only a rough estimate, given the fluctuation of damage from one fight to the next).

Please, if anybody else has access to a ToE, feel free to test it and place your results here.

What level is the ToE? Named or unnamed?

I said on the opening post that the ToE is level 500k. However, it is unnamed.

I don't think naming affect the effect of ToE. only its growth rate

Whoops, missed that. Are the numbers for reduction obtained using the same damage source, or multiple? If the latter, is it consistent across all sizes of FBs/AMFs?

Naming a tattoo adds levels. Which does add to the effect as a by product.

Enchantments etc....

Teh Enchantments cast Antimagic Field on Joe (0.44)
Teh Enchantments cast Antimagic Field on Hubbell Man's familiar (0.39)
A Tattoo of Endurance lvl 4,727,321

Battle 1 vs Hubbell with ToE

Ranged Combat
Joe takes damage from his own Fireball (267236)!
Joe's Fireball hit The Enchantments [21577], Evasion Minion [15662], A Slinky [19079], The Man [2670]
A Slinky absorbs damage [21577]
A Slinky absorbs damage [15662]
A Slinky absorbs damage [2670]
Hubbell Man's familiar takes damage from his own Magic Missile (304558)!
Hubbell Man's familiar's Magic Missile hit The Man [351934]
A Slinky absorbs damage [351934]
A Slinky regenerated 174,000 HP

The Man's shot ricocheted near Joe
Joe takes damage from his own Fireball (286325)!
Joe's Fireball hit The Enchantments [26913], Evasion Minion [26693], A Slinky [27552], The Man [2511]
A Slinky absorbs damage [26913]
A Slinky absorbs damage [26693]
A Slinky absorbs damage [2511]
Hubbell Man's familiar takes damage from his own Magic Missile (326313)!
Hubbell Man's familiar's Magic Missile hit The Man [286384]
A Slinky absorbs damage [286384]
A Slinky regenerated 174,000 HP

The Man's shot went wide of Joe
Joe takes damage from his own Fireball (305413)!
Joe's Fireball hit The Enchantments [40052], Evasion Minion [31721], A Slinky [17917], The Man [20490]
A Slinky absorbs damage [40052]
A Slinky absorbs damage [31721]
A Slinky absorbs damage [20490]
Hubbell Man's familiar takes damage from his own Magic Missile (348067)!
Hubbell Man's familiar's Magic Missile hit The Man [247680]
A Slinky absorbs damage [247680]
A Slinky regenerated 174,000 HP

The Man's shot went wide of Joe
Joe takes damage from his own Fireball (324501)!
Joe's Fireball hit The Enchantments [30365], Evasion Minion [24087], A Slinky [27210], The Man [7261]
A Slinky absorbs damage [30365]
A Slinky absorbs damage [24087]
A Slinky absorbs damage [7261]
Hubbell Man's familiar takes damage from his own Magic Missile (369821)!
Hubbell Man's familiar's Magic Missile hit The Man [156286]
A Slinky absorbs damage [156286]
A Slinky regenerated 174,000 HP

The Man overshot Joe
Joe takes damage from his own Fireball (343590)!
Joe's Fireball hit The Enchantments [43332], Evasion Minion [25069], A Slinky [19641], The Man [5822]
A Slinky absorbs damage [43332]
A Slinky absorbs damage [25069]
A Slinky absorbs damage [5822]
Hubbell Man's familiar takes damage from his own Magic Missile (391575)!
Hubbell Man's familiar's Magic Missile hit The Man [460073]
A Slinky absorbs damage [400500]
A Slinky regenerated 174,000 HP
The Man regenerated 59,573 HP

The Man undershot Joe
Joe takes damage from his own Fireball (636277)!
Joe's Fireball hit The Enchantments [47843], Evasion Minion [39732], A Slinky [64007], The Man [35639]
A Slinky absorbs damage [47843]
A Slinky absorbs damage [39732]
A Slinky absorbs damage [35639]
Hubbell Man's familiar takes damage from his own Magic Missile (725140)!
Hubbell Man's familiar's Magic Missile hit The Man [837823]
A Slinky absorbs damage [400500]
Hubbell Man takes damage from his own Decay (236120)!
Hubbell Man's Decay hit The Enchantments for no damage
A Slinky regenerated 174,000 HP
The Man regenerated 108,000 HP

Melee Combat
Joe takes damage from his own Fireball (636277)!
Joe's Fireball hit The Enchantments [63410], Evasion Minion [53642], A Slinky [48654], The Man [42441], Mary Frances Boyd [109400], Hubbell Man's familiar [101523], Hubbell Man [133111], Dave [76184]
A Slinky absorbs damage [63410]
A Slinky absorbs damage [53642]
A Slinky absorbs damage [42441]
Joe cries "Hubbell Rules!"
Mary Frances Boyd takes damage from his own Decay (153030)!
Mary Frances Boyd's Decay hit The Enchantments for no damage
Hubbell Man's familiar takes damage from his own Magic Missile (725140)!
Hubbell Man's familiar's Magic Missile hit The Man [811520]
A Slinky absorbs damage [400500]
Hubbell Man takes damage from his own Decay (153413)!
Hubbell Man's Decay hit The Enchantments for no damage
Dave takes damage from his own Decay (160471)!
Dave's Decay hit The Enchantments for no damage
A Slinky regenerated 174,000 HP
The Man regenerated 108,000 HP
R.I.P. Hubbell Man's familiar

The Man stumbled swinging at Joe
Joe takes damage from his own Fireball (636277)!
Joe's Fireball hit The Enchantments [70196], Evasion Minion [63098], A Slinky [60509], The Man [25583], Mary Frances Boyd [127847], Hubbell Man [82976], Dave [130611]
A Slinky absorbs damage [70196]
A Slinky absorbs damage [63098]
A Slinky absorbs damage [25583]
Mary Frances Boyd takes damage from his own Decay (90114)!
Mary Frances Boyd's Decay hit The Enchantments for no damage
Hubbell Man takes damage from his own Decay (100462)!
Hubbell Man's Decay hit The Enchantments for no damage
Dave takes damage from his own Decay (95268)!
Dave's Decay hit The Enchantments for no damage
A Slinky regenerated 174,000 HP
The Man regenerated 108,000 HP

The Man's blow was dodged by Joe
Joe takes damage from his own Fireball (636277)!
Joe's Fireball hit The Enchantments [82960], Evasion Minion [42566], A Slinky [60503], The Man [32790], Mary Frances Boyd [129703], Hubbell Man [85118], Dave [124516]
A Slinky absorbs damage [82960]
A Slinky absorbs damage [42566]
A Slinky absorbs damage [32790]
Mary Frances Boyd takes damage from his own Decay (40875)!
Mary Frances Boyd's Decay hit The Enchantments for no damage
Hubbell Man takes damage from his own Decay (58892)!
Hubbell Man's Decay hit The Enchantments for no damage
Dave takes damage from his own Decay (46037)!
Dave's Decay hit The Enchantments for no damage
A Slinky regenerated 174,000 HP
The Man regenerated 108,000 HP
R.I.P. Joe

The Man pulverized Mary Frances Boyd with Voice of Reckoning [1814028]
The Man draws strength from his weapon! [28321]
The Man pulverized Mary Frances Boyd with Voice of Reckoning [944099]
The Man pulverized Mary Frances Boyd with Voice of Reckoning [1036379]
The Man cries "Thats a wrap!!"
Mary Frances Boyd takes damage from his own Decay (0)!
Mary Frances Boyd's Decay hit The Enchantments for no damage
Hubbell Man takes damage from his own Decay (45700)!
Hubbell Man's Decay hit The Enchantments for no damage
Dave takes damage from his own Decay (35724)!
Dave's Decay hit The Enchantments for no damage
A Slinky regenerated 174,000 HP
The Man regenerated 108,000 HP
R.I.P. Mary Frances Boyd

The Man pulverized Hubbell Man with Voice of Reckoning [1153767]
The Man draws strength from his weapon! [31664]
The Man crushed Hubbell Man with Voice of Reckoning [997007]
The Man pulverized Hubbell Man with Voice of Reckoning [1114004]
The Man cries "Thats a wrap!!"
Hubbell Man takes damage from his own Decay (0)!
Hubbell Man's Decay hit The Enchantments for no damage
Dave takes damage from his own Decay (24752)!
Dave's Decay hit The Enchantments for no damage
A Slinky regenerated 174,000 HP
The Man regenerated 108,000 HP
R.I.P. Hubbell Man

The Man crushed Dave with Voice of Reckoning [935227]
The Man draws strength from his weapon! [19802]
The Man crushed Dave with Voice of Reckoning [834084]
The Man pulverized Dave with Voice of Reckoning [1105957]
The Man cries "Thats a wrap!!"
Dave takes damage from his own Decay (0)!
Dave's Decay hit The Enchantments for no damage
A Slinky regenerated 174,000 HP
The Man regenerated 108,000 HP
R.I.P. Dave


Battle 2 vs Hubbell w/o my ToE

Ranged Combat
Joe takes damage from his own Fireball (267236)!
Joe's Fireball hit The Enchantments [141327], Evasion Minion [103273], A Slinky [103945], The Man [44859]
A Slinky absorbs damage [141327]
A Slinky absorbs damage [103273]
A Slinky absorbs damage [44859]
Hubbell Man's familiar takes damage from his own Magic Missile (304558)!
Hubbell Man's familiar's Magic Missile hit The Man [579530]
A Slinky absorbs damage [400500]
A Slinky regenerated 174,000 HP
The Man regenerated 108,000 HP

The Man undershot Joe
Joe takes damage from his own Fireball (286325)!
Joe's Fireball hit The Enchantments [107421], Evasion Minion [69229], A Slinky [70871], The Man [2864]
A Slinky absorbs damage [107421]
A Slinky absorbs damage [69229]
A Slinky absorbs damage [2864]
Hubbell Man's familiar takes damage from his own Magic Missile (326313)!
Hubbell Man's familiar's Magic Missile hit The Man [469530]
A Slinky absorbs damage [400500]
A Slinky regenerated 174,000 HP
The Man regenerated 108,000 HP

The Man's shot flew past Joe
Joe takes damage from his own Fireball (305413)!
Joe's Fireball hit The Enchantments [174459], Evasion Minion [128288], A Slinky [66012], The Man [22275]
A Slinky absorbs damage [174459]
A Slinky absorbs damage [128288]
A Slinky absorbs damage [22275]
Hubbell Man's familiar takes damage from his own Magic Missile (348067)!
Hubbell Man's familiar's Magic Missile hit The Man [486340]
A Slinky absorbs damage [400500]
A Slinky regenerated 174,000 HP
The Man regenerated 108,000 HP

The Man's shot ricocheted near Joe
Joe takes damage from his own Fireball (324501)!
Joe's Fireball hit The Enchantments [158953], Evasion Minion [119150], A Slinky [89653], The Man [44652]
A Slinky absorbs damage [158953]
A Slinky absorbs damage [119150]
A Slinky absorbs damage [44652]
Hubbell Man's familiar takes damage from his own Magic Missile (369821)!
Hubbell Man's familiar's Magic Missile hit The Man [493901]
A Slinky absorbs damage [400500]
A Slinky regenerated 174,000 HP
The Man regenerated 103,301 HP

The Man overshot Joe
Joe takes damage from his own Fireball (343590)!
Joe's Fireball hit The Enchantments [189383], Evasion Minion [85601], A Slinky [138154], The Man [71891]
A Slinky absorbs damage [189383]
A Slinky absorbs damage [85601]
A Slinky absorbs damage [71891]
Hubbell Man's familiar takes damage from his own Magic Missile (391575)!
Hubbell Man's familiar's Magic Missile hit The Man [520334]
A Slinky absorbs damage [400500]
A Slinky regenerated 174,000 HP
The Man regenerated 108,000 HP

The Man's shot went wide of Joe
Joe takes damage from his own Fireball (636277)!
Joe's Fireball hit The Enchantments [261253], Evasion Minion [140862], A Slinky [141310], The Man [172756]
A Slinky absorbs damage [261253]
A Slinky absorbs damage [140862]
A Slinky absorbs damage [172756]
Hubbell Man's familiar takes damage from his own Magic Missile (725140)!
Hubbell Man's familiar's Magic Missile hit The Man [832905]
A Slinky absorbs damage [400500]
Hubbell Man takes damage from his own Decay (236120)!
Hubbell Man's Decay hit The Enchantments for no damage
A Slinky regenerated 174,000 HP
The Man regenerated 108,000 HP

Melee Combat
Joe takes damage from his own Fireball (636277)!
Joe's Fireball hit The Enchantments [331486], Evasion Minion [155836], A Slinky [160333], The Man [193368], Mary Frances Boyd [79660], Hubbell Man's familiar [93262], Hubbell Man [107674], Dave [115065]
A Slinky absorbs damage [331486]
A Slinky absorbs damage [155836]
A Slinky absorbs damage [193368]
Mary Frances Boyd takes damage from his own Decay (159692)!
Mary Frances Boyd's Decay hit The Enchantments for no damage
Hubbell Man's familiar takes damage from his own Magic Missile (725140)!
Hubbell Man's familiar's Magic Missile hit The Man [999065]
A Slinky absorbs damage [15395]
Hubbell Man takes damage from his own Decay (159111)!
Hubbell Man's Decay hit The Enchantments for no damage
Dave takes damage from his own Decay (151762)!
Dave's Decay hit The Enchantments for no damage
A Slinky regenerated 174,000 HP
The Man regenerated 108,000 HP
R.I.P. Hubbell Man's familiar

The Man swung wildly at Joe
Joe takes damage from his own Fireball (636277)!
Joe's Fireball hit The Enchantments [308882], Evasion Minion [147108], A Slinky [47882], The Man [153959], Mary Frances Boyd [86959], Hubbell Man [114781], Dave [128842]
A Slinky absorbs damage [194756]
Joe cries "Hubbell Rules!"
Mary Frances Boyd takes damage from his own Decay (104442)!
Mary Frances Boyd's Decay hit The Enchantments for no damage
Hubbell Man takes damage from his own Decay (97759)!
Hubbell Man's Decay hit The Enchantments for no damage
Dave takes damage from his own Decay (88906)!
Dave's Decay hit The Enchantments for no damage
A Slinky regenerated 174,000 HP
The Man regenerated 108,000 HP

The Man's blow was dodged by Joe
Joe takes damage from his own Fireball (636277)!
Joe's Fireball hit The Enchantments [349546], Evasion Minion [238486], A Slinky [63983], The Man [175594], Mary Frances Boyd [128986], Hubbell Man [71557], Dave [118334]
A Slinky absorbs damage [139694]
Joe cries "Hubbell Rules!"
Mary Frances Boyd takes damage from his own Decay (52154)!
Mary Frances Boyd's Decay hit The Enchantments for no damage
Hubbell Man takes damage from his own Decay (59832)!
Hubbell Man's Decay hit The Enchantments for no damage
Dave takes damage from his own Decay (42484)!
Dave's Decay hit The Enchantments for no damage
A Slinky regenerated 174,000 HP
The Man regenerated 108,000 HP
R.I.P. Joe

The Man pulverized Mary Frances Boyd with Voice of Reckoning [1888168]
The Man draws strength from his weapon! [36136]
The Man crushed Mary Frances Boyd with Voice of Reckoning [922893]
The Man pulverized Mary Frances Boyd with Voice of Reckoning [1260272]
The Man cries "Thats a wrap!!"
Mary Frances Boyd takes damage from his own Decay (0)!
Mary Frances Boyd's Decay hit The Enchantments for no damage
Hubbell Man takes damage from his own Decay (46430)!
Hubbell Man's Decay hit The Enchantments for no damage
Dave takes damage from his own Decay (32968)!
Dave's Decay hit The Enchantments for no damage
A Slinky regenerated 174,000 HP
The Man regenerated 108,000 HP
R.I.P. Mary Frances Boyd

The Man crushed Hubbell Man with Voice of Reckoning [1193106]
The Man draws strength from his weapon! [32169]
The Man crushed Hubbell Man with Voice of Reckoning [1218009]
The Man pulverized Hubbell Man with Voice of Reckoning [952632]
The Man cries "Thats a wrap!!"
Hubbell Man takes damage from his own Decay (0)!
Hubbell Man's Decay hit The Enchantments for no damage
Dave takes damage from his own Decay (22842)!
Dave's Decay hit The Enchantments for no damage
A Slinky regenerated 174,000 HP
The Man regenerated 108,000 HP
R.I.P. Hubbell Man

The Man crushed Dave with Voice of Reckoning [1152823]
The Man draws strength from his weapon! [18274]
The Man pulverized Dave with Voice of Reckoning [1243963]
The Man crushed Dave with Voice of Reckoning [1210902]
The Man cries "Thats a wrap!!"
Dave takes damage from his own Decay (0)!
Dave's Decay hit The Enchantments for no damage
A Slinky regenerated 174,000 HP
The Man regenerated 108,000 HP
R.I.P. Dave

JS > As far as the fireball damage that i tested is concerned, i only have two fireball mages on my fightlist... one of them was doing such sporratic damage (anywhere between 350k and 750k in one shot), with the battles running so short (2 rounds, max) that it was just impossible to use the data from those fights. So my fireball info was purely from one person on my fightlist.

However, the AMF info i took was from a couple people. The first fight, the AMF damage was under 100k per round, the second person I fought, the AMF ranged from 100k-300k per round (but after several fights on each person, the AMF damage shelled out was almost exactly the same from one battle to the next, making it very easy to record the mitigation from the ToE). On both players, after 4 battles with the ToE on, and 4 with the ToE off, for EACH players, I saw a consistant 17k being reduced from the AMF damage, while my tattoo was almost exactly 500k. Which shows that the ToE is, now, only reducing AMF damage by 3.4% of its level.

Can you also run a test vs. a tiny AMF to see if you can get it under the cap? Find someone who casts on you for 0.01.

Direct Damage 2,759,812
vs a 0.1 amf

with the ToE
Eric takes damage from his own Cone of Cold (184858)!

without the ToE
Eric takes damage from his own Cone of Cold (284918)!

that was with the toe and nothing but the toe on my CoC caster
The toe is
A Batfink Band-Aid lvl 2,886,374

thats all i have for now, hope that helps

we probably need a more samples... because basing on this

with the ToE
Eric takes damage from his own Cone of Cold (184858)!

without the ToE
Eric takes damage from his own Cone of Cold (284918)!

1184858/284918=0.351188763082711516997873072253

35% reduction.... but as i said... 1 sample doesnt make a whole research... we need more numbers....

i just finish seperating draco's data into its components... im going to go catch some sleep first before running the numbers... :) ciao

Well we do know AMF is a constant during the entire battls.

So using the TOE for that is a good standard.

Just have to make sure the TOE is large enough to "cap" all the AMF backlash.

put it this way... from the wiki... TOE is supposed reduce AMF damage by 20% ... but from this numbers it reduces 35%... so yep :) we need more data :) as i said will run through draco's damage samples later :) till then bed! =x

Ten dollars says that the ToE reduces AMF backlash by 1/30th of its level.

lostling > The data that j'bob gave was a 2mil+ ToE vs a .01 AMF. He purposely fought a low AMF to see what the damage reduction cap was for AMF.

If you look at the 100k the ToE reduced off the AMF, and compare it to the tat's level (2.88mil), you'll see that it comes out to 3.4%. Which is the exact mitigation i recorded with my own ToE.

Actually, taking the naming into account, it reduces exactly 1/30th of the level. +/- 0.

Also, that was a .1, not a .01.

1/30th is still 3.333% unto infinity, so i don't really see what you're trying to drive at, since you're basically saying the same number that i am.

no one is being aggressive here >.<

I was wondering if RoBF damage is fairly constant, maybe that'll be a good way to test?

It's more precise. The same reason people use pi instead of 3 when trying to find a circumference. Anyways, now that the maximum reduction has been established, can someone run a test vs. a 0.01 AMF with a large ToE so we can see what the cap is relative to the damage done?

considering we don't actually know how much on the tat the naming gives, saying 1/30 is just an estimation in and of itself. Need to do more testing with various level un-named ToEs for the flat %, then test it with a named on to find out the exact numbers naming gives.

If mine is considered a large ToE ( I know there's much bigger out there) I'd be happy to if I could find a .01 amf.
The .1 was the best I could do at the moment.

3/4 > I was going to test on a couple RBF teams, but the ones on my fightlist don't get to melee before i kill them, and i didn't really feel like hunting any down to test on. Not to mention losing the BA on losses in the process.

Naming adds exactly 4%.

Eric takes damage from his own Cone of Cold (184858)!
Eric takes damage from his own Cone of Cold (284918)!
Reduction: 100060

A Batfink Band-Aid lvl 2,886,374
*1.04 = 3001828.96 / 30 = 100060.9653.

Which is .0346666666666666666 unto infinity. 3.4% JUST LIKE I SAID.

Thank you for proving my point.

I'm not sure what that guy was casting when I submitted those numbers but I may have made an error.
with my ToE AND my NS on the battle log shows:
'The Rake' cast Antimagic Field on Eric (0.10)

and in that battle:
Eric takes damage from his own Cone of Cold (30970)!


with just the NS on, taking off the ToE
Eric takes damage from his own Cone of Cold (123877)!

the above is casting : Direct Damage 2,759,812

I am trying to be helpful but I'm not good at all with numbers but I'm trying to at least be consistent with my info.
I'll be happy to conduct any tests if someone wants to tell me what to do.

(man I hope I'm not screwing with peoples heads.)
/sigh

oh and duh. the ToE (right after these fights) is currently showing
A Batfink Band-Aid lvl 2,891,043 (sorry bout the triple)

And 123877/4 is 30969.25. Looks like the cap is 75% for this damage as well.

i retract my last post, it's almost exactly 1/30th of tat level. Not 3.4%... i had some numbers mixed up.

In any case, it seems that damage is capped at 75% as it has always been.

J'bob... Would you please stop ravaging my team for the sake of research?! Leave me alone! ...

On a more serious note, I can untrain my AMF and train up to an effective .01 effect to j'bob's team if need be... Tell what effective level of AMF I would need to get .01 and consider it done.

84.73257056 84.83437104 81.64510077 94.04801712 39.27251393 81.46097854 81.5845934 77.71190808 92.77259222 26.25948121
74.94623956 61.44245909 61.12373185 12.32541899 39.00624028 69.93548747 53.7309509 53.34847822 -5.209497207 26.80748834
77.04217037 75.27360314 72.85796522 8.013468013 49.07266521 79.91189907 78.36440275 76.25071957 19.51178451 55.43858206
80.89686889 79.7843055 69.6496492 83.73869032 68.35681645 83.14429608 82.1626225 73.22027871 85.65178557 72.07954392
77.11938242 70.71412717 85.78325637 91.90162885 11.58121514 79.66167326 73.96811304 87.36289455 92.80144787 21.40552457
79.59938754 76.24784993 76.13494527 79.85231028 41.09340247
81.68710024 71.7936704 54.70455028 79.37032578 -0.590463498
80.87098701 65.57791524 69.65440677 78.05169418 18.77205187
77.27416942 57.10770318 -26.3710789 83.38323839
76.26635693 82.15157284 5.43894472 81.32624122

78.86700976 70.82803257 43.49008967 80.38558124 9.968885953

these are all the numbers i got from draco's data...
i did an average on all of them and came out with this
63.17227417%
if you delete all the impossible numbers like -negative and percentages below 30% we get

73.83883326%

74% for what? ToE mitigation cap?

73% for max damage reduction under cap... which im pretty certain still stays at 75% so im guessing that jon changed the damage cap... from 50% main and 40% aura
to
40% main and 32% aura

So is the ToE still one of the best (if not the best) choices for a CoC based team?

It is for me. :)

TOE = damage reduction cap just slightly lesser... it will be pretty hard to test the cap of the TOE.... whether its a flat decrease of 50-30% and 40-20% or 50-40% and 40-32%

could someone please do some testing at the edge of the damage caps?... theoratically it should be 40% main 32% aura

Much love to Green Pants and his Harmonics for being our testing subject.

Static Cast on Minions:
Lucy cast Antimagic Field on flame (0.38)
Lucy cast Antimagic Field on Ovalor (1.00)
Lucy cast Ablative Shield on all friendly Minions (234367)
Oval cast Antimagic Field on Ausrap (0.62)

ToE: A Tattoo of Endurance lvl 616,457

Melee Only:
This was a test to see how much damage I did without and then with the ToE. First was without...

Ausrap takes damage from his own Cone of Cold (164991)!
Ausrap's Cone of Cold hit flame [11085], Oval [10033], Left [12127], Cholera [10739]
Ausrap takes damage from his own Cone of Cold (164991)!
Ausrap's Cone of Cold hit flame [7583], Oval [9062], Left [11805], Cholera [8532]

Then was with.

Ausrap takes damage from his own Cone of Cold (144443)!
Ausrap's Cone of Cold hit flame [7041], Oval [11819], Left [6690], Cholera [7392]

Ausrap takes damage from his own Cone of Cold (144443)!
Ausrap's Cone of Cold hit flame [7886], Oval [9302], Left [12138], Cholera [6491]

Ausrap takes damage from his own Cone of Cold (144443)!
Ausrap's Cone of Cold hit flame [10712], Oval [9379], Left [10352], Cholera [9001]

Ausrap takes damage from his own Cone of Cold (164991)!
Ausrap takes damage from his own Cone of Cold (144443)!

assuming the AMF damage is under cap...
1 - (144443/164991) = 0.124540126431138668169778957641% reduction