Revisited: Organized Debate of CB topics (in Off-topic)

AdminQBnovice [Cult of the Valaraukar] May 4 2009 4:08 AM EDT

I tried a few things (unsuccessfully) to get legitimate debate concerning balance related issues going that followed a format allowing for calm friendly discussion, as well as clear concise arguments as to the merits of the individual perspectives.

What do we need to do to structure these debates in such a manner as to make them readable by all by the newest people, so that through them folks can get a better understanding of the game? The animosity currently pervading every topic in forums is loathsome and painful to read. It's left me with a strong desire never to post in General again.

Jon made it clear the wiki isn't the place for it, I tried to bring the debate to chat and found it to be too high traffic and prone to emotional outbursts (pot kettle black anyone?) for decent discussion.

AdminNightStrike May 4 2009 4:14 AM EDT

Hmm. Perhaps you could do it through contests, where people submit editorial type entries. Have people pay to post an entry, and collect them all as self contained thoughts.

QBOddBird May 4 2009 4:16 AM EDT

Maybe get everyone to post in a certain format:

The first post containing the thesis/argument, supporting evidence

All posts thereafter:

Post addressed (1st is default)
supporting evidence
past precedent

Just a format similar to that?

AdminNightStrike May 4 2009 4:18 AM EDT

I bet we could find formal debate rules (a la college Debate Team style) somewhere online that apply to forums. I'll google around.

AdminNightStrike May 4 2009 4:20 AM EDT

AdminNightStrike May 4 2009 4:34 AM EDT

We can adapt these:

QBOddBird May 4 2009 4:36 AM EDT

I really think it's viable. We could have great debate/discussion threads going with those rules in play, and I think it would attract a more intelligent, logical crowd to CB.

three4thsforsaken May 4 2009 5:07 AM EDT

You would think. But I'm skeptical.

Wasp [C and S Forgery Lmtd.] May 4 2009 5:26 AM EDT

Post it under a contest. Impose rules and an entry fee. Strongest posts win prizes. It could work... right?

Marlfox [Cult of the Valaraukar] May 4 2009 6:58 AM EDT

I think we should have a debate about it.

{WW]Nayab [Cult of the Valaraukar] May 4 2009 7:06 AM EDT

Hmm interesting concept this, one i personally hopes comes to fruition, and good luck to those involved in creating such a revolutionary change to the CB experience.
Thanks for your contribution to the community.

AdminNightStrike May 4 2009 2:37 PM EDT

As per novice's idea, see the new debate forum.
This thread is closed to new posts. However, you are welcome to reference it from a new thread; link this with the html <a href="/bboard/q-and-a-fetch-msg.tcl?msg_id=002kCh">Revisited: Organized Debate of CB topics</a>